Medicare Advantage → Original Medicare + Medigap + Part D
2026–2027 State-by-State Rules for All 50 States
Legacy Wealth Services | Medicare Reference Guide · Updated: November 20, 2026
Several carriers, including some Providence Health Plans and PacificSource products, are discontinuing Medicare Advantage coverage in certain areas for 2027. If your plan is one of them, this guide explains your options.
The most important distinction: being eligible to leave Medicare Advantage does not automatically mean a person can obtain a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) without medical underwriting.
There are three separate decisions, and each has different rules:
- Original Medicare: Can you disenroll from Medicare Advantage and return to Medicare Parts A and B?
- Medigap: Can you buy Medicare Supplement insurance without medical underwriting?
- Part D: Can you enroll in a standalone Prescription Drug Plan (PDP)?
1. Federal rules that apply in all 50 states
| Circumstance | Return to Original Medicare | Medigap guaranteed issue |
|---|---|---|
| Medicare Advantage plan terminates or stops serving the area | Yes, through a special enrollment opportunity | Yes |
| Individual moves outside the MA service area | Yes | Yes, when federal eligibility requirements are met |
| First joined MA when first eligible for Medicare at 65 and leaves within the first 12 months | Yes, during an applicable enrollment period | Yes, under the federal trial right |
| Dropped Medigap to try MA for the first time and returns within 12 months | Yes, during an applicable enrollment period | Yes, generally to the previous Medigap policy |
| Voluntarily leaves MA after several years | Yes, during AEP, MA OEP, or another applicable enrollment period | Not automatically |
| Has a serious health condition and wants different coverage | Yes, during an applicable enrollment period | Not automatically |
| Lives in a state with expanded Medigap protections | Yes, during an applicable enrollment period | Depends on that state's laws |
Federal guaranteed-issue protections are particularly valuable when a Medicare Advantage plan terminates coverage. Under the standard federal rule, affected individuals generally have a Medigap application window beginning 60 days before the MA coverage ends and extending 63 days afterward.
The right generally applies to specified Medigap policies, not necessarily every available supplement.
2. The three enrollment periods to distinguish
Annual Enrollment Period (AEP): October 15–December 7. You may leave Medicare Advantage and return to Original Medicare effective January 1. You can also select a standalone PDP. However, AEP alone does not create a federal Medigap guaranteed-issue right.
Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (MA OEP): January 1–March 31. Existing MA enrollees may make one qualifying election to return to Original Medicare and enroll in a standalone PDP. Again, this does not automatically guarantee Medigap eligibility.
Special Enrollment Period (SEP): qualifying circumstances. Events such as an MA plan termination or departure from a service area can create additional enrollment rights, including federal guaranteed-issue protection for Medigap.
The decisive question is not simply “Can I leave Medicare Advantage?” It is “Do I have a guaranteed-issue right to obtain Medigap, and if so, which plans?”
3. State-by-state Medigap eligibility rules
The table addresses this situation: an individual age 65 or older has been enrolled in Medicare Advantage for more than 12 months and now wants to return voluntarily to Original Medicare, buy Medigap, and enroll in Part D. For every state, assume a valid Medicare enrollment period is available.
- Underwriting normally required: you can apply for Medigap, but acceptance is not guaranteed unless another federal or state protection applies.
- Guaranteed issue (GI): an insurer must accept an eligible application under the applicable rules.
- Limited GI: additional rights exist, but restrictions apply.
The table distinguishes rights to enter Medigap from rules allowing people already enrolled in Medigap to change policies. Those are not interchangeable.
| State | MA → Medigap without federal GI event | Important state-specific rule |
|---|---|---|
| Alabama | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Alaska | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Arizona | Underwriting normally required | No general annual GI right for MA-to-Medigap transitions. |
| Arkansas | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| California | Underwriting normally required | Additional GI rights may apply when an MA plan reduces benefits, increases cost sharing, or terminates a treating provider's contract. Birthday rule applies to existing Medigap holders. |
| Colorado | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Connecticut | Year-round GI | Continuous Medigap open enrollment without medical underwriting. |
| Delaware | Expanded annual access | MA enrollees can enter Medigap during federal Medicare enrollment periods. Insurers cannot deny the application, but medical underwriting may affect premiums and pre-existing-condition limitations. |
| Florida | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Georgia | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Hawaii | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Idaho | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule is primarily for existing Medigap policyholders. |
| Illinois | Limited additional access | One major insurer offers broader GI access for people 65+. The state also has a restricted Medigap birthday rule. |
| Indiana | Underwriting normally required | New Medigap birthday rule effective January 2026; applies to existing Medigap holders. |
| Iowa | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Kansas | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Kentucky | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule applies to existing Medigap holders. |
| Louisiana | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule for existing Medigap holders, with insurer restrictions. |
| Maine | Limited annual GI | Insurers must offer at least Plan A during a designated one-month annual period. Maine also extends certain MA trial rights to three years. |
| Maryland | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule for existing Medigap holders; additional protections for certain qualifying events. |
| Massachusetts | Year-round access in practice | All insurers currently offer continuous Medigap enrollment. State regulations require an annual GI period. |
| Michigan | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Minnesota | Limited GI, ages 65–70 | A new one-time annual enrollment opportunity took effect August 1, 2026, subject to age and other eligibility requirements and possible premium surcharges. |
| Mississippi | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Missouri | Underwriting normally required | Anniversary rule allows existing Medigap policyholders to switch to equivalent coverage with another company. |
| Montana | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Nebraska | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Nevada | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule for existing Medigap holders. |
| New Hampshire | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| New Jersey | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| New Mexico | Underwriting normally required | New Medigap birthday rule begins January 1, 2027, for existing policyholders. |
| New York | Year-round GI | Continuous Medigap open enrollment without medical underwriting. |
| North Carolina | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| North Dakota | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Ohio | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Oklahoma | Underwriting normally required | Additional switching protections exist for current Medigap policyholders. |
| Oregon | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule allows existing Medigap holders to change to equal or lesser coverage. MA plan termination creates separate GI rights. |
| Pennsylvania | Underwriting normally required | Additional protections exist for initial Medigap eligibility, including certain disability-related circumstances. |
| Rhode Island | Annual GI for qualifying MA enrollees | During October 15–December 7, eligible MA enrollees can purchase Medigap without medical underwriting, subject to continuous-coverage rules. |
| South Carolina | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| South Dakota | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Tennessee | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
| Texas | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI applies; additional protections address certain disability-related circumstances. |
| Utah | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule applies to existing Medigap holders, generally within their existing carrier. |
| Vermont | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply; no general year-round MA-to-Medigap GI entitlement established by the reviewed state guidance. |
| Virginia | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule for existing Medigap holders. |
| Washington | Underwriting normally required | Existing Medigap policyholders enjoy broad switching rights. These do not automatically cover people coming from Medicare Advantage. |
| West Virginia | Underwriting normally required | A restricted, biennial birthday-rule opportunity began in June 2026 for existing Medigap holders. |
| Wisconsin | Underwriting normally required | Different Medigap standardization; certain expanded trial rights apply. |
| Wyoming | Underwriting normally required | Birthday rule for existing Medigap holders. |
| Washington, D.C. | Underwriting normally required | Federal GI and trial rights apply. |
Sources: KFF’s October 2026 national review, the May 2026 NAIC state-law chart, and current state insurance regulations. State-level rights can differ for people under 65, people with ESRD, and people who delayed Part B enrollment.
Key takeaways
- Connecticut and New York provide the clearest continuous guaranteed-issue access. Massachusetts provides continuous enrollment in practice.
- Maine’s annual protection generally guarantees access to Plan A, not necessarily Plan G.
- Delaware, Rhode Island and Minnesota now provide additional opportunities for qualifying Medicare Advantage enrollees.
- Washington does not provide an unrestricted right for every Medicare Advantage enrollee to move into Medigap without underwriting. Its switching provisions primarily protect people who already have Medigap.
4. States with expanded protections
Connecticut and New York
Beneficiaries age 65 and older can purchase Medigap throughout the year without medical underwriting. For example, a 75-year-old with a chronic condition who has been in Medicare Advantage for eight years can ordinarily buy Medigap without a health-based denial. The actual return to Original Medicare must still be coordinated with an appropriate Medicare enrollment period.
Massachusetts
Massachusetts requires an annual guaranteed enrollment opportunity, but insurers currently offer Medigap enrollment throughout the year. Because Massachusetts uses its own standardized Medigap structure, the same standardized Plan G sold in most other states is not available.
Rhode Island
During AEP (October 15–December 7), qualifying individuals who have maintained coverage continuously since initial Medicare enrollment, without a disqualifying gap exceeding 90 days, can obtain Medigap on a guaranteed-issue basis. This provides an annual pathway from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare plus a supplement.
Delaware
Effective January 1, 2026, Delaware established additional rights for Medicare Advantage beneficiaries returning to Original Medicare during AEP or MA OEP. The insurer cannot reject an eligible Medigap application under the expanded state provision. However, health-based pricing and certain pre-existing-condition limitations may still apply, so this is not the same as a federal GI right.
Minnesota
Beginning August 1, 2026, Minnesota established a one-time Medigap guaranteed-issue opportunity for qualifying individuals ages 65–70 who are applying for Medigap for the first time. It operates during specified Medicare enrollment periods, and a premium surcharge can apply.
Maine
Under certain circumstances, people who try Medicare Advantage can return to Original Medicare within three years, instead of the usual federal one-year trial period, and exercise expanded Medigap rights. Separately, Maine requires insurers to offer Plan A during a designated one-month period each year. These are two different protections with different eligibility requirements.
5. Oregon: when your Medicare Advantage plan is ending for 2027
Consider this example: a 74-year-old Oregon resident with Providence Medicare Advantage that terminates December 31, 2026, who has diabetes, heart disease and a previous hospitalization, and wants Original Medicare + Medigap Plan G + a PDP.
Would this person qualify? Generally, yes, if the specific Medicare Advantage coverage is genuinely terminating and the applicable guaranteed-issue requirements are met. A qualifying Medigap plan could ordinarily be obtained without medical underwriting, even with significant pre-existing conditions.
Oregon’s guaranteed-issue regulation, OAR 836-052-0142, provides protections for qualifying Medicare Advantage terminations, and Oregon’s rules include Medigap Plans M and N among the available guaranteed-issue options for applicable qualifying events. That is broader than the narrower federal minimum protections.
Critical dates for plans ending December 31, 2026
| Date | Significance |
|---|---|
| October 15, 2026 | Annual Enrollment Period begins |
| December 7, 2026 | Annual Enrollment Period ends |
| December 8, 2026 | Additional nonrenewal SEP begins |
| December 31, 2026 | Existing MA plan coverage terminates |
| January 1, 2027 | Original Medicare and replacement coverage should begin if properly coordinated |
| February 28, 2027 | Nonrenewal SEP for MA/PDP elections ends |
| March 4, 2027 | Generally, final day of the 63-day post-termination Medigap GI application window |
The nonrenewal SEP dates are confirmed in CMS’s 2027 enrollment guidance.
Whenever possible, complete the Medigap and PDP enrollment before December 31, even though additional enrollment opportunities may exist. This avoids unnecessary prescription coverage gaps and confusion over effective dates. Also verify your actual nonrenewal notice: a carrier leaving a county or terminating a contract is different from an ordinary change in plan benefits.
6. Don’t forget Part D
Medigap and Part D are separate insurance products. When you return from a Medicare Advantage plan that includes drug coverage to Original Medicare, a standalone PDP generally must be selected to keep Medicare prescription drug coverage. Evaluate the PDP separately, considering:
- Your prescription medications, dosages and frequencies
- Your preferred pharmacies
- Total estimated annual prescription costs
- Formulary restrictions, including prior authorization, step therapy and quantity limits
- Whether you qualify for Extra Help
Guaranteed-issue rights for Medigap do not determine which PDP is appropriate. PDP enrollment is generally not subject to medical underwriting, but you must have an applicable enrollment period. For people whose MA plans terminate, the special enrollment opportunity can provide additional time to select prescription coverage.
7. How we help you decide
- Why are you leaving Medicare Advantage? Is your plan terminating, are you moving, are you in a trial period, or do you simply want different coverage?
- Establish Medigap eligibility. Determine whether federal or state guaranteed-issue rights apply. If not, review the insurer’s underwriting guidelines before disenrolling from Medicare Advantage.
- Identify eligible Medigap plans. Plan G may be available under certain federal guaranteed-issue rights, but not every qualifying event or state law permits every standardized plan.
- Compare carriers. Where eligible, we compare Plans G, N and high-deductible G on premiums, rate history, underwriting requirements and household discounts.
- Quote Part D using your medication list and pharmacies.
- Compare the complete alternatives. Option A: Medicare Advantage premium, expected medical and drug costs, provider access and maximum out-of-pocket exposure. Option B: Part B premium, Medigap premium, PDP premium, deductibles, expected prescription costs and coverage characteristics.
- Coordinate enrollment and keep records. Keep your nonrenewal notice, evidence of guaranteed-issue eligibility, Medigap application, PDP confirmation, effective dates and consent documentation.
Important
This table is a screening reference, not a substitute for the full state Medigap statutes, regulations and insurer requirements. It captures the principal rules but not every specialized qualifying event, age exception or carrier-specific provision. Eligibility for a specific transaction is verified against current state insurance department rules and the insurer’s guaranteed-issue guidelines.
Or call 503-832-8555 (Medicare line)
Medicare Disclosure: Legacy Wealth Services represents Medicare Advantage HMO, PPO, and PFFS organizations that have a Medicare contract. Enrollment depends on the plan’s contract renewal. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 6 organizations which offer 19 products in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options. We are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. Calls to the phone numbers on this website are answered by a licensed insurance agent.